Loyalty Program Spending Rises as Consumer Satisfaction Lags
Businesses are boosting loyalty investment, but only 32% of U.S. consumers say their rewards programs consistently exceed expectations, new research shows.
U.S. companies are ramping up spending on loyalty programs even as a significant gap persists between consumer expectations and actual program performance, according to new research from arrivia released Monday.
The study found that nine in ten consumers — 90% — expect to remain loyal to their preferred brand or organization, signaling strong underlying demand for meaningful reward relationships. Yet only 32% of respondents said their loyalty program consistently exceeds expectations, exposing a substantial delivery shortfall that businesses have yet to close.
Read more Target Hospitality Posts Q3 2026 Results Amid Major Contract Wins →
The disconnect suggests that increased investment alone may not translate into stronger member satisfaction. Consumers appear willing to stay engaged but are signaling that program quality, relevance, and tangible value remain persistent pain points that spending increases have not yet addressed.
The findings carry strategic weight for brands competing in an environment where loyalty programs have proliferated across retail, travel, financial services, and other sectors. When the majority of members report underwhelming experiences, the risk of disengagement rises even among customers who express intent to stay loyal, analysts note.
Continue reading at All Financial Services & Investing.
